Home › Top 6 › The Routledge Guidebook to Descartes' Meditations
Review: The Routledge Guidebook to Descartes' Meditations — the dress rehearsal
★★★★☆4.4 / 5.0 (editorial rating)
Verdict: the book that turns the Meditations from a wall into a staircase. Hatfield walks the text meditation by meditation — what each argument claims, what it assumes, where it is weakest — so that when you open the original, you climb with a guide who has marked every hold. If the Meditations is your goal, this is the best money you will spend on the way there.
- Title
- The Routledge Guidebook to Descartes' Meditations (The Routledge Guides to the Great Books)
- Author
- Gary Hatfield
- Publisher
- Routledge (2014)
- Length
- 364 pp.
- Difficulty
- Intermediate ★★☆ — ~2 weeks alongside the text
Check price & availability on the Amazon product page
What it is — in three lines
A full-length reading companion to the Meditations from Routledge's Guides to the Great Books series, by a University of Pennsylvania scholar who has spent a career on Descartes' science and psychology. It proceeds in the order you actually read: context first, then each of the six Meditations in turn, then the aftermath. This 2014 guidebook is the current, expanded descendant of Hatfield's well-used 2003 Routledge guide.
Why a walking companion beats a summary
Summaries tell you what Descartes concluded; the Meditations asks you to do the meditating yourself, in first person, over six days. That is why cold readers stall: the text is an exercise, not a report. Hatfield's guide respects the exercise. For each Meditation he sets the scene, restates the argument step by step, flags what a seventeenth-century reader would have taken for granted, and then — crucially — airs the standard objections, from Descartes' own contemporaries onward. You arrive at the original already knowing where the fights are.
Three highlights
1. The historical stage-setting
Hatfield opens with the world the Meditations was written to overturn — school philosophy, the old physics, what "science" meant in 1641. Ten minutes of this context saves hours of misreading; you stop treating Descartes' moves as arbitrary and start seeing what each one is for.
2. The hard parts taken seriously
The proofs of God, and above all the Cartesian circle — does Descartes prove God by trusting the very faculty God is supposed to guarantee? — get patient, fair treatment rather than a wave of the hand. When you hit these passages in the original, you will be glad someone rehearsed them with you.
3. The scientist's Descartes, again
Like Sorell but at walking pace, Hatfield keeps Descartes' physics and psychology in view — the Meditations as the metaphysical foundation for a new science of nature. The Sixth Meditation, where mind meets body, reads completely differently with that frame in place.
How to use it (and how not to)
One warning and one tip. The warning: at 364 pages the guide is longer than the work it guides — do not let it replace the original. The failure mode is reading Hatfield instead of Descartes and feeling finished; the guide is scaffolding around a building you still have to enter. The tip: read it in alternation — Hatfield's chapter on the First Meditation, then the First Meditation itself, and so on. That rhythm, guide-then-text, is what the book is built for, and it is how it earns the "dress rehearsal" name we gave it.
Check price & availability on the Amazon product page